Araby

8/10

 I looked up papers about James Joyce, and there were many papers, Dubline itself was interpreted as a place to monitor children. Adults can see children playing in the plaza at every angle, and it is the background of trying to be included in such social norms. However, in this surveillance city, the boy found Mangan's sister while looking around the city and fell in love with her. However, the boy always hides and looks at the girl only in hidden places. The boy can feel joy while looking at the girl, but the girl can't. Also, only the scene where the boy looks at the girl is depicted, but the girl looking at the boy is not depicted. When I look at this, I think I can feel the male gaze that the teacher said. In the process of looking at a girl, the image created by the boy through the insertion of subtle sentences is added and deteriorated. However, as this city itself is a space for surveillance, it has not created anything more than a deteriorated gaze. No further development is made other than just watching. In the end, the boy can be seen as a person who has not broken through the norms of the world.

댓글

  1. Garrioch2022년 3월 23일 오후 5:53

    I have never heard this detail about the urban design of Dublin, but it makes sense! If you find a good paper, do keep the link and share it. There is a TON of stuff in JSTOR about Joyce and definitely Araby. This is a very good analysis you present with some continuation of points I made in class that have gone deeper. Indeed, the story is one-sided and we have NO IDEA what Mangan's sister is thinking or if she even thinks about the boy at all. He is so far from practicality in this story (he is buying a gift for a girl he has barely said a word to?) that indeed he is a "creature" driven by vanity. Good work Hyunseop.

    답글삭제
    답글
    1. Hyunseop Shin2022년 3월 24일 오전 6:27

      Thanks!! I also want to share this paper but it’s Korean paper so… 🥲🥲
      But if you still want to see it
      http://www.riss.kr/search/detail/DetailView.do?p_mat_type=be54d9b8bc7cdb09&control_no=03a37604fa7d7d75ffe0bdc3ef48d419&keyword=%EC%95%A0%EB%9F%AC%EB%B9%84
      This is the link!!
      It’s about Lacan's Theory of Mirror and Freud’s psychanalysis about house and place.

      삭제

댓글 쓰기

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

The Sisters - James Joyce (1914)

 I read this short story similar to “Doubt” by John Patrick Shanley. There is also Father Flynn who is preist. Its story about Flynn and Sister Aloysius is arguing whether Flynn made a sexual assault on his church boy or not. In “Doubt” the boy was the first student who was black in the school. However, Father Flynn was kind to him. Sister Aloysius was doubting because Flynn was extremely kind to the boy, and Flynn is saying because he was the only black in the school so he should take care more. However, “The Sisters” of James Joyce shows suspicion because of the boy and Father Flynn as too close.  Both stories don’t have the answer and a clear ending. It makes doubt to readers. However, I am wondering if this doubt, just because the reason that they are too close is reasonable. (791words)
자세한 내용 보기

The Lady With the Dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899)

  8/10 While reading this short story, I thought Grouv and Anna were both crazy people. Both of them were married, but they cheated on each other while travling and went to a place where they lived. This is crazy. No matter how much Grouv hated his wife, how can he do this when he has children? However, reading this short story, the more I felt that the writer wanted to look at it in a good way. There is a saying in Korean. If I do it, romance. If others do it, affair. It seems to feel different depending on the perspective. However, although this short story is an omniscient writer's point of view, it felt like Grouv was explaining it himself because readers can see the main character's mind. In other words, since the main character and the narrator's position are closer, the relationship between infidelity seems to have felt like romance. If the relationship between the narrator and the protagonist is separated, I think it will be more focused on infidelity than romance. ...
자세한 내용 보기